| Year | Show | Pantomime |
| 1973 | The Gondoliers | |
| 1974 | The Mikado | Dick Whittington |
| 1975 | Iolanthe | Sleeping Beauty |
| 1976 | La Vie Parisienne | Cinderella |
| 1977 | The Belle of New York | Aladdin |
| 1978 | Yeoman of the Guard | Mother Goose |
| 1979 | Orpheus in the Underworld | Sinbad the Sailor |
| 1980 | Pirates of Penzance | Jack and the Beanstalk |
| 1981 | Oklahoma | Babes in the Woods |
| 1982 | Fiddler on the Roof | Journey to Oz |
| 1983 | Showboat | Robin Hood |
| 1984 | The Arcadians | Cinderella |
| 1985 | Music Man | Jack and the Beanstalk |
| 1986 | Orpheus in the Underworld | Dick Whittington |
| 1987 | Finians Rainbow | Sleeping Beauty |
| 1988 | Little Mary Sunshine | Aladdin |
| 1989 | New Pirates of Penzance | Mother Goose |
| 1990 | Irene | Sinbad the Sailor |
| 1991 | Calamity Jane | Cinderella |
| 1992 | Guys and Dolls | Sleeping Beauty |
| 1993 | Brigadoon | Dick Whittington |
| 1994 | Anything Goes | Jack and the Beanstalk |
| 1995 | Billy | Treasure Island |
| 1996 | Sweet Charity | Aladdin |
| 1997 | Me and My Girl | Cinderella |
| 1998 | Oklahoma | Beauty and The Beast |
| 1999 | My Fair Lady | Mother Goose |
| 2000 | Hello Dolly | Dick Whittington |
| 2001 | Music Man | Treasure Island |
| 2002 | Mack and Mabel | The Three Musketeers |
| 2003 | Jesus Christ Superstar | The Princess and the Pea |
| 2004 | Fiddler on the Roof | Sleeping Beauty |
| 2005 | Hot Mikado | Cinderella |
| 2006 | Guys and Dolls | Jack and the Beanstalk |
| 2007 | Sweet Charity | Elves and the Shoemaker |
| 2008 | Calamity Jane | Aladdin |
| 2009 | Night Out | Babes in the Woods |
| 2010 | Oklahoma | Beauty and The Beast |
| 2011 | The Wizard of Oz | The Three Musketeers |
| 2012 | All Shook Up | Treasure Island |
| 2013 | Copacabana | Cinderella |
| 2014 | Anything Goes | Sleeping Beauty |
| 2015 | Sugar | Robin Hood |
| 2016 | The Witches of Eastwick | Frozen Solid |
| 2017 | Seussical | Entangled |